A negotiated municipal bond sale takes three separate firms: a financial advisor on the issuer's side, an underwriter who buys the bonds, and bond counsel on legality and tax. MSRB Rule G-23 keeps the first two apart: the same dealer cannot advise on an issue and then underwrite it.
Who does what on a negotiated bond sale?
Three seats, and each one answers a different question for the issuer.
The financial advisor answers what to do: whether to sell competitively or negotiate, how to shape the maturities, when to come to market, and which firms should be invited to bid for the underwriting. The underwriter answers who sells the bonds: it buys the issue from the issuer and resells it to investors, carrying the risk of whatever does not sell. Bond counsel answers whether the bonds are valid and whether their interest is tax exempt, and its opinion is what the buyers' side reads before anything closes.
GFOA's debt-issuance best practices treat the three selections as three separate processes, and the reason is in the seats themselves. The advisor's advice shapes the very sale the underwriter is paid for. That is a conflict before anyone has done anything wrong, which is why it has a rule.
Why can't the same firm advise and underwrite?
Because the advice comes first, and the money follows it. An advisor recommending a negotiated sale, a particular structure or a particular timing is recommending the kind of underwriting a firm would like to be paid for. A firm holding both interests would be grading its own work with the issuer's money.
The MSRB says the same thing in four words. Rule G-23 is described by the MSRB, in the notice accompanying its current form, as "solely a conflicts rule."
GFOA states the practice for issuers in terms that leave nothing to interpretation. Its best practice on selecting underwriters recommends "that a firm hired as a financial advisor should not be allowed to resign in order to underwrite the proposed negotiated sale of bonds."
That recommendation is written for the case an issuer is most tempted to allow: the advisor the board already trusts, offering to take the underwriting as well. GFOA's answer is decided before the selection, not negotiated after it.
What does Rule G-23 prohibit?
The rule works on the dealer. Once a dealer has a financial advisory relationship with an issuer, it may not, for that same issue, acquire the bonds as principal, join a syndicate that buys them, or act as the issuer's agent in placing them.
Three details matter to a bank. First, the limits reach past the firm: a dealer controlling, controlled by, or under common control with the advisor carries the same restrictions, so an affiliate cannot take a seat the parent cannot. Second, remarketing is included: the advisor cannot be the remarketing agent for the issue, and a firm can take over as successor remarketing agent only after the advisory relationship has been over for a year. Third, the relationship itself has paperwork: it must be evidenced by a writing, delivered to the issuer, stating the basis for the advisor's compensation, entered into before the relationship, at its start or promptly after.
One narrow path exists. A dealer may act as the issuer's agent in placing the entire issue with a state, local or federal government entity as part of that entity's own plan of financing, compensated only for advisory services and not for the placement. Read it as the exception it is: it keeps a government financing itself, not a door back to one firm holding both seats in the market.
And the rule is a floor, not a ceiling. More restrictive state and local law still applies, and the rule says so.
How does the split change the three selections?
Each seat is filled by its own process. GFOA's compilation covers selecting advisors, selecting bond counsel and selecting underwriters as three separate best practices, and the underwriter's selection is the one run through a request for proposals. GFOA recommends the RFP process explicitly, "in order to promote fairness, objectivity and transparency," because the issuer is comparing firms on ideas, distribution and cost rather than taking the lowest bid the way a competitive sale does.
The advisor's selection comes first and shapes the rest. GFOA recommends hiring an outside advisor unless the issuer has sufficient in-house expertise and market access, and the advisor is the firm that then runs the underwriter selection, lending, in GFOA's words, "objective knowledge and expertise in the selection of underwriters." Once you have read the conflict rule above, that sentence explains itself: the firm guiding the selection cannot be a firm in the running.
Bond counsel's engagement runs on its own track, because the opinion it renders is what the validity of the bonds and the tax treatment of the interest rest on.
What does Rule G-23 not cover?
Bond counsel, first: the rule governs dealers, and the law firm giving the validity and tax opinion is engaged separately. Second, different issues: the bar runs to the issue the dealer advised on, so a firm that advised on last year's refunding is not disqualified from underwriting this year's new-money deal. Third, the issuer's own judgment: the rule closes one door, and everything around it, which firms are invited, what the RFP asks, how the responses are scored, stays with the issuer and its advisor.
That is where the work at a public finance bank divides. Finding the solicitations across a territory is a watch, because issuers start these sequences on their own calendars and the requests never all arrive in one place: approved portals, the group's own inboxes, each request scored against the criteria the group set, which is what the RFP watch does. Choosing which firm takes which seat is a person's decision every time, which is what the rule, and the recommendation on top of it, are there to protect.
What else is worth asking?
Can a financial advisor ever become the underwriter on the same issue?
Not while Rule G-23 applies. Advising the issuer on the issue is what disqualifies the firm from underwriting it, and the GFOA recommendation exists so issuers never have to negotiate that question mid-deal.
Who leads the selection of the underwriter?
The financial advisor, chosen first. GFOA describes the advisor as lending objective knowledge and expertise to the selection of underwriters, which is exactly the work a firm in the running cannot do impartially.
Is bond counsel selected the same way as the underwriter?
No. GFOA treats selecting bond counsel as its own best practice with its own process. Counsel renders the validity and tax opinion the closing depends on and is engaged directly by the issuer.
What does the rule require in writing?
The advisory relationship itself. Rule G-23 requires it to be evidenced by a writing, delivered to the issuer, that states the basis for the advisor's compensation, entered into before the relationship, at its start, or promptly after.
Sources
- Rule G-23 msrb.org
- best practice on selecting underwriters gfoa.org